If My Employer Drops the 401(k) Match, Should I Still Contribute?
With business tending to be slower for many right now, I have heard of cases where employers stopped matching employee 401(k) contributions. Along with the market’s downturn, this leaves people wondering what to do. What would you do if your employer stopped matching your 401(k) contributions? Here’s my two bits.
Did the employer drop the match temporarily or permanently? If permanently, unless I really liked the investment options in the 401(k) or the contributions lowered my income in a way that had significant tax implications, I would stop contributing. However, I would continue to invest essentially that same portion of my income to mutual funds I like, which I would set up as Roth IRAs to be automatically withdrawn from my checking account each month. That way it would still feel like I never have the option to spend that money.
If the employer dropped the match temporarily, it’s not as clear. If there is a decent chance they will begin matching again within a year, I would keep contributing to the 401(k). The reason being that it’s a little less hassle to keep it going and you don’t risk the possibility of failing to invest the money somewhere else. There may also be tax implications to your paycheck. However, if the employer won’t be matching contributions again for at least a year, or you really dislike your investment options, I would probably stop contributing.
Hopefully that situation doesn’t arise, for both your sake and your employer’s. If it does, just be sure to continue to invest the money somewhere either by contributing to the 401(k) or in other investments, such as mutual funds. In fact if you don’t trust yourself to be sufficiently disciplined to continue to invest that money, I would recommend that you simply stick with the 401(k).
Those are my two bits. What are yours?
I'm Michael Crowther, and I'm passionate about sharing the peace of mind that comes from budgeting, saving (including debt elimination), and investing.
March 13th, 2009 at 10:47 am
Such a timely post… just yesterday Ryan and I were conversing about this. I said to Ryan, “I wonder what Michael thinks?” You must have had inspiration to post on this today, thanks!
March 17th, 2009 at 10:18 pm
In a recent Society for Human Resource Management poll this question was asked with the responses listed below:
Is your company freezing or planning to freeze its match or contributions to employees’ 401(k) plans?
7824 total votes
We have already done so
23% 1825 votes
We plan to do so
7% 517 votes
We do not plan to do so
57% 4437 votes
Not sure
13% 1045 votes
March 17th, 2009 at 11:31 pm
Thanks for adding those stats. While most don’t plan to freeze the match, it’s interesting to see nearly a quarter of them have. That percentage is higher than I expected and could potentially become 30% when you include those who plan to freeze the match.